Big Mountain Riding

Review & Images: Randy King

The 29er version of the Gary Fisher HiFi has been on my to-ride list for some time. Along with my curiosity, I brought some baggage with me into this short-term relationship. My best bike for three years was a 26″ wheel HiFi Deluxe. It helped me up my epic race game and went through 1,000’s of miles of mud and dust before coming to a sudden and calamitous demise when the frame broke in three places. These positive memories and nervousness about durability took turns coloring my opinion about how the big-wheeled version would ride. So, how did it go? Well, a bit like that … a mix of good and not-so-good.

Technically, there is no Gary Fisher HiFi. Gary’s bikes have been drawn into the Trek line-up, and now all that remains on the bike of Gary’s name is a copy of his signature on the frame. Hmmph, I say. I’ve met Gary Fisher (I know, I know, Jeremiah Bishop told me not to name drop), and it didn’t even take those meaningful 60-seconds for me to vote that  Fisher should have his own line-up in the Trek conglomerate.

Along with the bigger wheels, the HiFi Pro I tested sports a few other differences from my former bike. Trek has opened up the suspension linkage design a bit.  The bike also gets some upgrades, moving up to a Fox fork and adding three gears with the SRAM — 10 speed drive train. I tested the HiFi Pro model.

What I loved about my 26″ HiFi was its adapt-to-anything attitude. Above all, it was fun to ride. I am glad to see that this vibe is shared by the big wheel HiFi.

I chose the Witchback trail at Angler’s Ridge in Danville, VA for the test. This is a frequent up-and-down six mile loop with several short but gut-busting climbs and several quick and fast descents.  A mini-rock garden and a small drop-off add to the mix to make it a good test trail for trail and XC bikes.

The HiFi Pro tackles climbs with aplomb and good manners. It is stable and tracks well even on sudden steeps. The Bontrager 29-2 Team Issue tires are a good combination of fast and grippy for a trail bike.  The suspension is definitely more noticeable on climbs than it was on the 26″ HiFi – credit in part to the more open suspension design. It is also noticeable on the descents, where the HiFi has pretty good small-bump compliance without the harsh edge that sometimes plagued the 26″ bike.

What I didn’t like about my 26″ HiFi was its lack of durability. Durability is a key virtue in a bike that one hopes to ride for 100 KM or more at a time, over rough terrain.  The first time the frame broke on my 26″ HiFi, I had to climb the side of a mountain to get cell phone reception, limp for several miles out of the woods on stiff-soled cycling shoes, with a lump the size of a baseball on my thigh from a crash earlier in the ride. Durability is good. Unfortunately, the big-wheeled HiFi seems to bring its fragility with it. After less than 5 miles, I noticed some noise coming from the linkage. Hmm. The bolt that connects the top of the shock to the bike had worked loose.

The 29″ HiFi has 100 MM of travel, compared to the 120 of the 26″ version. And despite what so many say, a 29″ wheel is not the same as suspsension. In another words, I miss that extra 4/5 of an inch of travel. In its absence, it makes the bike feel more racy and less rideable.

Parting thoughts:

The $3,600 Gary Fisher HiFi Pro seems like a viable epic racer or enduro bike, and is up to frequent trail rides. While less “racy” than the Superfly 100, and costing less, it still feels less of a true trail bike than a high-priced bike meant mostly for going fast. A different set of tires and a wider riser bar might correct that, and you can get aboard a HiFi Plus for about $2,300, but stock the HiFi Pro feels like a long distance runner for those who can afford it.

© 2011 Big Mountain Riding

Review: Scott Schekman

Photos: Scott Schekman & Randy King

This is a review of a 2008 Gary Fisher HiFi Deluxe 29. (The newer, redesigned HiFi’s geometry resembles the Superfly 100 )

The HiFi 29 hooks up well on steep, technical terrain

I had been looking to demo the Gary Fisher HiFi 29 for more than a year. So, I jumped at the chance when one of the guys at a local bike shop was nice enough to let me borrow his for a week.  The HiFi Deluxe 29 features 100MM (4-inches) travel on both ends, courtesy of a Fox RP2 shock and a Fox F29 RLC fork. The rest of the components were a mix: Avid BB7 brakes, Shimano SLX crankset and XTR front derailleur, SRAM X.0 rear derailleur and throwback grip shifters.  I used my own wheels and tires, a Continental Mountain King (front) and Race King (rear) tires mounted on Stan’s arch rims laced to WTB Laserlite hubs. With the light wheelset, the bike weighed in at 26lbs 2oz (11.8KG) including the Eggbeater pedals.  I also set up the 17.5″ (44.45CM) frame tested with an 80MM stem, which worked well for my height.

A fan of big wheels, I currently own two 29er’s, both hardtails- one setup as a rigid single speed. I have owned and ridden 26” full suspensions, including the 26” HiFi.  Alright, enough of the details. I rode this bike at my local trails, Virginia’s Candler’s Mountain (now called Liberty Mountain trails). These are an epic (+/- 60-miles/96.6KM) mix of single track, steep climbs and descents, fast fire road and technical trails. Now, on to the best part- the riding itself.  I found this bike to be pretty responsive to pedaling input even with the rear shock’s Pro Pedal in full open mode – although it is not as responsive as the new Gary Fisher Superfly 100. The ride was good but not plush, similar to the 26” HiFi.  This bike climbs well, whether the rider is seated or standing. It really hooked up on the steep, technical climbs that I seem to search out.

One challenging climb especially surprised me; it’s a steep, rooty climb that I have only cleaned once out of about thirty attempts on my Salsa Mamacita.  I got it on my third try on this bike. I think full suspension with wagon wheels make a great combination in this situation. The steering and handling were very good and predictable at both slow and higher speeds.  Switch backs were not a problem either, whether going up or down. I noticed no flex in the frame, but heavier riders may.

Overall, the longer I rode this bike, the more I enjoyed it.  It does everything well.  If you are looking for a big wheel full suspension bike that you can ride (and race) in most situations, this one is worth looking into. In fact, you may want to start checking eBay and Craig’s List to find a used one for sale.

© Big Mountain Riding

Wagon Wheels and dual suspenders pair well on the HiFi 29

Review: Randy King

Photos: Scott Schekman & Randy King

Big wheels rolling over the cobblestones

Out of the corner of my eye I could see those skinny, semi-slick hoops spinning away over all the obstacles the trail had to offer – looking even skinnier because of their bigger diameter. This Gary Fisher Superfly 100 was my first real ride on a 29″ bike, and yet if it weren’t for that  glimpse, I wouldn’t even know I was aboard a “big wheel” bike. Frankly, I rode away a bit confused. Not with the bike, which rides like what it is marketed as – a full-suspension racing bike that is as light as a hard tail – but with the 29″ experience. More on that later; to the bike.

Riding the roots and log crossings of Bedford VA’s Falling Creek Park, the Superfly’s suspension performed as the definition of efficiency. If you asked me if I noticed the suspension while riding I’d say no. However, I also stayed seated through little bumps and bops that would have bucked me about aboard a hard tail. This bike is a competent climbing and efficient-pedaling ride. And the bigger wheels do eat up obstacles that might make a rider balk on a 26″ wheel race bike. (Of course it’s easy to forget that only a few years ago, 100MM (4-inches) of travel would have been considered All Mountain. In other words, that suspension that is so easy to forget about on the Superfly 100 is big enough to handle a lot of terrain change, especially when paired with bigger wheels.)

The aluminum flat bar is not a good match on the carbon Superfly

The boldly-painted, $5,600 bike sports nice bling like the Truativ Noir carbon crank – a beauty -  the rockstar-white Fox F100 FIT RLC 29 and the SRAM X.O shifters and rear derailleur. Yet the carbon frame and high-end components feel poorly paired with seeming oddities like the XT front derailleur and the Bontrager aluminum stem and flat bar. These are mismatches in function as well as form. Riding along, the cockpit feels a little too upright for a racing machine, and the bar feels too narrow and not damped enough. Personally, I think a low-rise carbon bar would suit the bike better and function better as well.

Designed as a racer, the Superfly 100 is not made for the rougher side of big mountain riding. It did not seem like it would handle well in say, a rock garden. However, a few mod’s could turn it into an excellent marathon racer for those who are fit enough to get the most of the efficient pedaling platform while dealing with the dicier handling in the occasional rough stuff.

Now, to the 29″ obsession. I ride with many who extol the virtues of big wheels and some who deride the 26″ wheel. Even ignoring the extremists, I had high expectations that the big wheel would roll differently. It didn’t for me. Visually odd, when glimpsed out of the corner of the eye – yes. Good traction on slippery climbs – yes, compared to a 26″ with the same semi-slick tires. However, I’d have to say I’d rather have an extra inch of travel than bigger wheels on most days and on most trails. I will be riding more 29″ bikes – because they work well for so many in the big mountain riding scene – but for now I’ll keep rolling retro-style on my 26-er.

© Big Mountain Riding

The Superfly sports bold graphics on its carbon frame